Last updated on May 9th, 2024 at 07:40 pm

Quick Answer

  •  Houses can come back on the market for a variety of reasons, such as the seller not being able to find a buyer, the seller changing their mind, or the seller not being able to close on the sale.
  • Another a house may come back on the market is that the buyer was unable to close on the sale. This could be due to the buyer not being able to secure financing, or the buyer not being able to meet the seller’s terms.
  • Another 15% of home sales fail due to a buyer’s inability to sell their current home.
  • About 5% of home sales fail due to a buyer’s failure to meet conditions of the contract.

When it comes to the real estate market, sometimes houses end up making a surprising comeback.

These houses that return to the market, after initially being under contract or listed for sale, present an intriguing phenomenon.

Common Reasons for Houses Returning to the Market

There are various factors that can contribute to houses being relisted on the market. 

Contingency Issues: One significant factor that often leads to a house returning to the market are contingency issues.

During a real estate transaction, buyers and sellers agree to specific conditions or contingencies that need to be met for the sale to proceed.

These contingencies can involve factors such as home inspections, mortgage commitments, or title searches.

If any issues arise during the contingency period and cannot be resolved, the buyer may choose to back out of the deal, and the home will return to the market.

Contingency issues, such as inspection problems or difficulties securing a mortgage commitment, can be major red flags during a real estate transaction.

Buyer’s Remorse: Another common reason for a house returning to the market is buyer’s remorse.

Sometimes, buyers may experience a change of heart or have second thoughts about the purchase.

This could be due to emotional factors, financial changes, or simply feeling uncertain about the decision.

When buyers back out of a deal due to buyer’s remorse, the house is re-listed, and the search for a new buyer begins.

Inspection Issues: Home inspections play a vital role in the buying process as they reveal any underlying issues with the property.

If an inspection uncovers significant problems that the seller is unwilling or unable to address, the buyer may choose to terminate the contract.

In such cases, the house returns to the market, giving other potential buyers an opportunity to consider its condition and negotiate repairs or pricing.

Mortgage and financing challenges can also lead to a house returning to the market.

If a buyer is unable to secure a mortgage or encounters difficulties with their financing, they may not be able to proceed with the purchase. 

Definition of Coming Back on the Market:

When it comes to the real estate market, it’s not uncommon for houses to occasionally return to the market after being listed as “under contract” or “pending.”

This phenomenon is referred to as “Coming Back on the Market,” and it can be quite puzzling for both buyers and sellers involved in the transaction. 

Failed Financing or Mortgage Issues

Failed Financing or Mortgage Issues can be a significant factor why houses return to the market.

When a buyer’s financing falls through or they encounter mortgage issues during the transaction, it can lead to the collapse of the deal and the property being relisted. There are several reasons why this may happen:

Mortgage Approval Process: The buyer’s mortgage approval process could hit roadblocks due to various reasons.

It could be a result of changes in the buyer’s financial situation, an issue with their credit score, or changes in the lender’s policies.

Sometimes, buyers may fail to meet the necessary requirements to secure a mortgage loan.

Appraisal-related Problems: Another common issue arises if the home doesn’t appraise for the agreed-upon sale price.

When a home appraisal comes in lower than expected, it can create a discrepancy between the buyer’s expected mortgage amount and the actual value of the property. In such cases, the buyer may not be able to secure the required mortgage loan.

Inspection Issues home: During the home inspection process, if significant issues are discovered, it can create difficulties in obtaining financing.

Lenders may require repairs or fixes to be completed before approving the mortgage loan. If the seller is unable or unwilling to address these issues, the buyer’s financing may fall through.

Mortgage Commitment: A buyer’s financing can also be jeopardized if they fail to receive a mortgage commitment from their lender within the agreed-upon timeframe. 

This could happen if the buyer’s lender encounters delays, requires additional documentation, or discovers new information that affects the mortgage approval.

Inspection and Appraisal Contingencies

Inspecting a house thoroughly and getting an appraisal are crucial steps in the home buying process.

However, inspection and appraisal contingencies can also be the cause for a house returning to the market.

Home Inspection Contingency: During a home inspection, a qualified professional examines the property for any underlying issues or damages.

This can range from structural concerns to plumbing or electrical problems.

If the inspection reveals significant issues that the buyer is unwilling to address or negotiate, they may choose to terminate the contract.

Buyer’s Remorse: Sometimes, upon seeing the inspection report, the buyer may have second thoughts about their decision to purchase the property.

Inspection Issues: If the inspection uncovers major issues or repairs that the buyer is not willing to undertake, it may result in the buyer deciding to walk away from the deal.

Contingency Period: The buyer typically has a specific period, known as the contingency period, to review the inspection report and negotiate repairs or request a credit from the seller. 

Appraisal Contingency:

An appraisal is an assessment of the property’s value conducted by a qualified appraiser. 

If the appraised value is significantly lower than the agreed-upon sale price, it can create complications in the transaction.

Sale Price vs. Appraised Value: If the appraised value comes in lower than the sale price, it can hinder the buyer’s ability to secure a mortgage loan for the agreed-upon amount. 

Mortgage Commitment: Lenders rely on the appraisal to determine the property’s value and assess the mortgage amount they are willing to lend. A low appraisal can lead to the buyer’s mortgage commitment being denied or revised.

Buyer’s Remorse or Change of Heart

One of the most common reasons why houses return to the market is due to buyer’s remorse or a change of heart on the part of the homebuyer.

It is not uncommon for individuals to get caught up in the excitement of purchasing a new home, only to realize later on that it might not be the perfect fit for them.

This can happen for a variety of reasons, such as a sudden change in personal circumstances or simply a feeling of doubt and uncertainty.

Emotional Decision-Making: Buying a home is a significant financial decision that often involves strong emotions. 

It’s only natural to have second thoughts after making a significant commitment like purchasing a home, as doubts and uncertainties can creep in.

Homebuyers who experience buyer’s remorse might realize that the house they bought doesn’t align with their long-term goals or lifestyle preferences.

Financial Changes and Mortgage Commitment: Another common reason for buyer’s remorse is a significant financial change that occurs between the initial offer and the final agreement.

Unanticipated financial issues, such as a job loss or a decrease in income, can make buyers reconsider their ability to afford the home.

Sometimes, buyers may realize that they are not able to obtain a mortgage commitment due to unforeseen circumstances or stricter lending requirements.

If the buyer’s lender uncovers a major issue during the underwriting process or if the loan falls through, the buyer might need to withdraw their offer or renegotiate the terms of the purchase.

If an agreement cannot be reached, the buyer may choose to terminate the contract, resulting in the house being relisted.

Problematic Liens and title issues 

Lien and title issues can have a significant impact on real estate transactions.

These issues usually arise when there are unpaid debts or legal claims against the property.

Title issues can also arise if there are problems with the property’s ownership history.

For example, if there is a dispute over the title or if a previous owner did not sign the necessary documents correctly, it can create uncertainty and legal complications.

In such cases, resolving these issues may require additional time and legal procedures, leading to the house being put back on the market.

However, once the lien or title issues are resolved, the house can be relisted on the market. The title company will usually discover any issues with encumbrances on the property.

If you are a seller with liens on the property there are homebuyers that pay cash and can close quickly.

The process of putting listings back on the market

To relist a house, certain steps need to be followed. These include updating marketing materials and notifying potential buyers about the relisting.

It’s important to note that a house coming back on the market can impact the selling process and negotiations.

Since the listing agent already has all the photos and details of the property, resisting it is easy. 

Final Thoughts

Houses coming back on the market can happen for various reasons, including inspection issues, financing problems, and contingencies.

Sometimes it might be home buyers who plan on wholesaling the property but cannot find a buyer in time before the option period expires. 

From taking on too much debt to changes in loan requirements, these financial hurdles can cause previously under-contract homes to become available again.

Additionally, unexpected repairs or renovations can lead sellers to reconsider their asking price, prompting a return to the market.

Another factor to consider is market conditions.

Fluctuations in buyer demand, neighborhood developments, or shifts in the economy can create uncertainty.